All news
Case law June 12, 2026 6 min

Finland: the Supreme Administrative Court upholds the fine on Verkkokauppa.com. The failing: never having defined how long to keep the data

No breach, no attack. Just retention periods that were never set, and an account you had to create in order to buy. The Court reduced nothing

TL;DR for the DPO

Customer data was kept until the customer themselves asked for deletion. And because buying online required creating an account, individual purchase data was kept longer than necessary too. Storage limitation is an obligation on the controller, not an option to be delegated to the data subject's initiative.

The two failings, and both are mundane

The first: retention periods for customer account data had not been defined. They were not wrong, they did not exist. Data stayed until someone asked for it to be deleted, that is, potentially forever. Art. 5(1)(e) requires the opposite: that the controller determine in advance how long the data is needed, and that it be erased or anonymised when that period expires.

The second: buying on the site required creating an account. That apparently commercial choice has a precise legal effect: it pulls individual purchase data inside the perimeter of the account, and makes it live as long as the account does. Had guest checkout been possible, retention of purchase data would have been governed by tax and warranty rules, which have an end date.

856,000 → 792,639EUR
amount reduced on appeal, then upheld

The path, and why the reduction is not a win

  • March 2024: the Finnish DPA's sanctions board imposes EUR 856,000.
  • The Administrative Court reduces the amount to EUR 792,639, not because the infringement was less serious but because the cap must be calculated on the most recent turnover. It is a recalculation, not a softening of the finding.
  • 12 June 2026: the Supreme Administrative Court dismisses the appeal and does not amend the lower court's decision.

The contrast with last week's Dutch case

On 29 July the Dutch Council of State annulled an authority's fine because the investigation did not hold up. Here a Supreme Court upholds everything. The difference is not judicial severity: it is what the authority had to prove. In the Netherlands it had to establish that MAC addresses were personal data, and it stumbled there. In Finland it was enough to observe that a retention period had never been written down. Documentary findings survive litigation because there is nothing to interpret.

What to do now, across your clients

Four checks, half an hour of work

1) In the Art. 30 records, run down the retention column: every cell that says 'until withdrawal', 'as long as necessary' or is blank is precisely the Finnish finding. 2) Ask your e-commerce client whether one can buy without registering: if not, the account becomes the container that extends the life of everything else. 3) Check that deletion at expiry is automatic, not a manual procedure nobody performs. 4) Write down the criterion, not just the number: '10 years from the last purchase, under the Civil Code' is defensible, '10 years' on its own is not.

Official source:Korkein hallinto-oikeus - KHO 12.6.2026/1604Official source:Office of the Data Protection Ombudsman - Supreme Administrative Court upholds the penalty on Verkkokauppa.com

Looking for a workspace for your DPO work?

DPO Workspace is built by a certified DPO. 30-day free trial.

Start free

Related articles

Case law
C-12/25erasure and baptismal registers

CJEU Advocate General: the right to erasure can apply to baptismal registers too

A Belgian national baptised as a child asks the Diocese of Ghent to erase his data. The Diocese records his departure from the Church and crosses out his name, which remains legible. For the Advocate General the register is a filing system under the GDPR, objection can lead to erasure, and a legible crossing-out is not erasure. The Court has not yet ruled.

Oct 01, 2026 5 min
Case law
2 mln €in fines annulled by the court

The criminal record certificate that says nothing: Spain annuls two million

By judgment no. 359/2026 of 8 July 2026 the Audiencia Nacional annulled the two-million-euro fine the Spanish authority had imposed on Amazon Road Transport Spain for asking candidates for a criminal record certificate. The reasoning: Article 10 covers data relating to convictions and offences, and a certificate attesting the ABSENCE of convictions does not automatically fall within it. The decision can still be appealed.

Jul 08, 2026 6 min
Case law
200 €for the loss of control

Real employee data inside the test system: what loss of control is worth

Testing a new HR system with real data is not forbidden: transferring more fields than the test needs is. The German Federal Labour Court ordered an employer to pay two hundred euro because it had uploaded salary, home address, tax ID and marital status although it had agreed a list of nine fields with the works council. And it confirmed that a delayed answer to an access request is not, in itself, a damage.

Aug 21, 2026 5 min