Your cookie preferences

EDPB guidance · Art. 7 GDPR

We use technical cookies essential for the platform to work (login, security, sessions). We would also like to use analytics cookies to understand how to improve it.

You can accept all, reject all, or choose which categories to switch on.Your consent is valid for 6 months and you can withdraw it at any time from the footer.

You will find everything in our privacy notice.

All news
Enforcement September 7, 2026 5 min

The vendor's bug turned into a criminal conviction

An Irish department store pleaded guilty to five charges out of twenty-one over marketing emails you could not unsubscribe from. The cause was a third-party software fault. It did not help

What happened

On 7 September 2026, before Judge Halpin at the Dublin Metropolitan District Court, Brown Thomas Arnotts Limited pleaded guilty to five sample charges out of twenty-one, for breaches of Regulation 13 of Statutory Instrument 336 of 2011, the Irish rules on unsolicited marketing communications. The Court applied the Probation of Offenders Act and, in light of the conviction, ordered a payment of one thousand euro to a local charity and one thousand euro towards the authority's legal costs.

The origin of the problem is the part that most resembles what happens to everyone. A technical fault at the third-party software provider made it intermittently impossible to unsubscribe from marketing communications. Not a choice, not an aggressive strategy: a fault. And the defence did not help, because the controller remains the party accountable for what those working for it do with the data.

  • Three charges: failure to provide a valid address to opt out, contrary to Regulation 13(12).
  • Two charges: sending marketing communications without valid consent, Regulation 13(1).
  • Some complainants had withdrawn consent in person or by telephone, and kept receiving messages.
  • The authority had already issued a warning to the same company in March 2022.

The third point is the one a DPO should take to a client tomorrow morning. People had said stop using the channels at hand — in store, by phone — and the system kept writing to them because the only door wired up was the unsubscribe link. It is exactly the pattern of the Italian decision against BBVA this September: the person's wish recorded in one place and never propagated to the system that sends.

Why two thousand euro is not the story

In Ireland, breaches of the ePrivacy marketing rules do not end in an administrative fine: they are prosecuted criminally, and the authority takes the company before a judge. What remains is not the payment, which is symbolic, but the conviction of a listed retailer on the court record. Anyone assessing marketing risk by looking at the size of fines is reading the wrong column.

And there is the 2022 warning. A fault can happen to anyone; a fault on the very matter you were warned about four years earlier is something else, and that is what turns a technical problem into a prosecution. The practical question to put to every client who sends newsletters is one, and it is not about consent: who checks, and how often, that the unsubscribe link actually works and that a withdrawal arriving by another channel reaches the system that sends?

Official source:Data Protection Commission — DPC welcomes outcome of prosecution of marketing offences (08/09/2026)Official source:Data Protection Commission — Latest news

Looking for a workspace for your DPO work?

DPO Workspace is built by a certified DPO. 30-day free trial.

Start free

Related articles

Enforcement
€ 8.000for a 46-second call to a number on the opt-out register

Telemarketing: €8,000 for a call made 'by mistake' to a number on the opt-out register

In decision no. 642 of 23 September 2026 the Italian Garante fined Business School S.r.l., a Milan training company: a promotional call to a number on the public opt-out register, a request for access, erasure and objection answered after more than seven months, and a reply to the Garante not also sent to the complainant. Within 30 days the company must give a complete written reply.

Nov 12, 2026New 4 min
Enforcement
€ 28.000for online medical reports readable by changing a number in the URL

Online medical reports open to anyone who changed a number in the URL: €28,000 for a radiology centre and its vendor

In decisions no. 764 and 754 of 7 October 2026, the Italian Garante fined the Centro Radiologico Madonna della Bruna in Matera (€16,000) and the IT company MedStore Saronno (€12,000). An IDOR vulnerability let anyone read other people's reports by editing the end of the web address, and reports stayed online well beyond the 45 days allowed. Handing the platform to a vendor does not relieve the controller of checking it.

Nov 12, 2026New 5 min
Enforcement
€ 25.500for former employees' mailboxes left active and an access request answered after 9 months

Former employee's mailbox kept active and read: €25,500 fine for Techpartner

In decision no. 796 of 20 October 2026, the Italian Garante fined Techpartner, a Modena supplier of food-industry equipment: €9,500 for answering an access request after nine months and €16,000 for rules that kept former employees' mailboxes active and readable. The company must bring its internal IT policies into line within 60 days.

Nov 12, 2026New 4 min