All news
Enforcement September 22, 2026 6 min

«Not unlawful, the medical management authorised it»: the Italian DPA says no, EUR 24,000

A colleague opens the complainant's health record to check whether she has Covid and organise the shifts. The employer argues it was lawful because it served the work. The authority separates the two roles: whoever acts as employer does not enter the care record

In two lines

Italian DPA, decision no. 616 of 3 September 2026 (doc. web no. 10293994): EUR 24,000 against the Friuli Centrale university health authority for breach of Arts. 5(1)(a), (b), (c) and (f), 9, 25 and 32 GDPR, Art. 75 of the Italian Privacy Code and the Health Dossier Guidelines of 4 June 2015.

In 2022 a colleague from the ward opens the complainant's health record — an employee and at the same time a patient of the same facility — to check whether she had Covid-19 and to draw up the shifts. In the criminal complaint the employer itself files with the Udine prosecutor, that access is described as «not unlawful», because it was «carried out on the instructions of the medical management» and «for the performance of the work». During the investigation further accesses emerge, by healthcare professionals who were not treating the complainant.

Why the defence does not hold

The health record exists to help the professional place the patient's condition within their care pathway: that, and only that, is what makes consulting it lawful. An organisational need — knowing which staff you can count on — is a different purpose, and must be met with dedicated tools. The authority adds a practical argument worth more than many admonitions: the record is inherently incomplete, because the data subject can mask entries, and the masked ones may be exactly those the organisational purpose would need. Using it to plan shifts is not only unlawful: it is inefficient.

What the authority ordered, within sixty days:

  • Limit access to the record to care purposes only, excluding staff acting as the data subject's employer
  • Introduce access limits configured in the system, not left to individual behaviour
  • Deploy anomaly detection that flags suspicious conduct automatically
  • Report the measures taken to the authority within sixty days of notification, under Art. 58(2)(d)

The detail that makes the case

Since 2024 the employer says it has an anomaly detection system: it consists of examining an Excel file collecting the results of queries on the viewer's audit log. It is worth reading twice. Access monitoring that exists as a spreadsheet someone looks at by hand is not a technical measure under Art. 32: it is a good intention with a technical name. And when the employer tries to explain the accesses it cannot attribute, it suggests that someone «took over» an unattended workstation — which is the exact description of the control that is missing.

What to ask your healthcare client

1) Ask whether there is a technical separation between those who access to treat and those who access to administer, and have it shown to you in the configuration, not in the procedure. 2) Ask how an anomalous access is detected: if the answer contains the word «Excel», you have found your finding. 3) Ask for evidence of the last alert raised and what happened next: a system that has flagged nothing in three years is not a quiet system, it is an off system. 4) Check that staff know that access without a care relationship is also unlawful access to a computer system under Art. 615-ter of the Italian criminal code, and that the facility has already reported such cases.

Official source:Italian Data Protection Authority, decision of 3 September 2026, register no. 616, doc. web no. 10293994

Looking for a workspace for your DPO work?

DPO Workspace is built by a certified DPO. 30-day free trial.

Start free

Related articles

Enforcement
€ 8.000for a 46-second call to a number on the opt-out register

Telemarketing: €8,000 for a call made 'by mistake' to a number on the opt-out register

In decision no. 642 of 23 September 2026 the Italian Garante fined Business School S.r.l., a Milan training company: a promotional call to a number on the public opt-out register, a request for access, erasure and objection answered after more than seven months, and a reply to the Garante not also sent to the complainant. Within 30 days the company must give a complete written reply.

Nov 12, 2026New 4 min
Enforcement
€ 28.000for online medical reports readable by changing a number in the URL

Online medical reports open to anyone who changed a number in the URL: €28,000 for a radiology centre and its vendor

In decisions no. 764 and 754 of 7 October 2026, the Italian Garante fined the Centro Radiologico Madonna della Bruna in Matera (€16,000) and the IT company MedStore Saronno (€12,000). An IDOR vulnerability let anyone read other people's reports by editing the end of the web address, and reports stayed online well beyond the 45 days allowed. Handing the platform to a vendor does not relieve the controller of checking it.

Nov 12, 2026New 5 min
Enforcement
€ 25.500for former employees' mailboxes left active and an access request answered after 9 months

Former employee's mailbox kept active and read: €25,500 fine for Techpartner

In decision no. 796 of 20 October 2026, the Italian Garante fined Techpartner, a Modena supplier of food-industry equipment: €9,500 for answering an access request after nine months and €16,000 for rules that kept former employees' mailboxes active and readable. The company must bring its internal IT policies into line within 60 days.

Nov 12, 2026New 4 min