What happened
Following a report, the Garante's staff searched the Ministry of Justice's online database of lower-court rulings for decisions with the role 'Minors': 3,702 results. Adding the word 'resident' left 806, from 2023 onwards. In about 22% of rulings concerning minors, the home address of the parents, or of the minor, was not masked. In decision no. 811 of 20 October 2026 the Garante declared the processing unlawful.
The Ministry, contacted urgently in June, masked the data and explained that it is testing automatic services to anonymise rulings 'at source'. It submitted no defence in the proceedings. Juvenile court rulings are no longer available in the database.
What the Garante decided
- Article 52(5) of the Italian Privacy Code requires anyone disseminating rulings to omit names and any data, including about third parties, from which a minor's identity can be inferred even indirectly: it always applies, even without a note from the judge.
- The parents' address is precisely such data: the Garante's 2010 guidelines on reproducing rulings for legal information already said so.
- The infringement is not 'minor': it concerns judicial data, disseminated on a large scale, which the law prohibits from being disseminated.
- No further corrective measures, since the Ministry has already masked the data and is working on automatic anonymisation.
In the published version of the decision the part on the penalty is omitted: the Garante does not state the financial outcome, and it is not reconstructed here.
The check for anyone publishing documents about people
This applies to public bodies, schools, professional orders, law firms and legal journals. Take ten recently published documents and search inside them for addresses, parents' names, schools attended and dates of birth: that is where masking fails, not in the name at the top. If masking is done by software, ask how it is checked and on what sample.
The lesson goes beyond justice: masking the name is not enough, because identity can be rebuilt from details. And the check belongs before publication, not after a complaint.
In DPO Workspace the Sentinel compares this decision with clients' records of processing, including those involving minors, and the Inspection rehearsal, in beta, helps check what is published and with what safeguards.
Official source:Garante per la protezione dei dati personali — Newsletter n. 556 del 12 novembre 2026Official source:Garante per la protezione dei dati personali — provvedimento n. 811 del 20 ottobre 2026 [doc. web 10319074]Looking for a workspace for your DPO work?
DPO Workspace is built by a certified DPO. 30-day free trial.
Start free