What happened
On 30 December 2024 a user on the public opt-out register since 31 August received a 46-second promotional call from Business School S.r.l., a Milan training company. When he objected, the operator spoke of 'explicit consent', refused to say where it came from and hung up. The same day the user asked for access, erasure and objection. The reply came on 7 August 2025, more than seven months later, and only after the authority stepped in: a generic apology and the offer of a phone call. In decision no. 642 of 23 September 2026 the Garante imposed a fine of €8,000.
The company showed that it buys lists from a supplier who says it checks them against the opt-out register, and the Garante found it plausible that the number was dialled by mistake. That reduced the seriousness but did not erase the infringement: the contact happened, without consent given after registration.
What the Garante decided
- A dialling error is no excuse: if an operator can type a number outside the filtered list, the technical measures that should prevent it are missing (Art. 24, 25 and 32 GDPR, cited for accountability).
- Difficulty finding the data is no reason for silence: at least an interim reply is due within one month (Art. 12(3)), and an extension must be communicated with reasons (Art. 12(4)).
- An informal phone call is not a reply: answers to rights requests must be written, complete and traceable.
- The Garante's requests must be carried out as instructed: not sending the reply to the complainant as well breaches the duty to cooperate (Art. 31 GDPR, Art. 157 of the Italian Privacy Code).
In the company's favour: a single episode, short duration, no prior infringements and the reminder given to staff afterwards; against it, the seven-month wait and the lack of an automatic check. Within 30 days it must send the data subject a complete written reply and tell the Garante what it has done. The injunction will be published.
The check for anyone doing telemarketing, even a little
Ask how a number is dialled in your calling system: if an operator can type it by hand, add a block that accepts only numbers from the checked list. Keep the supplier's opt-out check report for each list. And decide who answers a rights request received during a call: within one month, in writing.
The case shows how much handling requests weighs compared with the call itself: 46 seconds of contact became a fine above all because of seven months of silence and a reply to the Garante only half carried out.
In DPO Workspace data subject requests are logged with their one-month deadline, and the Inspection rehearsal, in beta, includes a specific question on marketing: consents, objections and checking of contact lists.
Official source:Garante per la protezione dei dati personali — Newsletter n. 556 del 12 novembre 2026Official source:Garante per la protezione dei dati personali — provvedimento n. 642 del 23 settembre 2026 [doc. web 10310017]Looking for a workspace for your DPO work?
DPO Workspace is built by a certified DPO. 30-day free trial.
Start free