What happened
For the competition for 400 notary posts announced in 2024, the Ministry of Justice made the written-test results available on a table in the lobby of its building, before the turnstiles: a list of 1,229 candidates, admitted and not admitted, with date of birth, report and envelope numbers and a score for each paper. Meanwhile a member of the examining board, on his own initiative, had sent the National Council of Notaries the list of those admitted with his marking notes, and the Council shared it with notaries registered on its platform before the official publication. With decisions no. 761 and 762 of 7 October 2026 the Garante fined the Ministry EUR 20,000 and the Council EUR 15,000.
For the Ministry, the key is the sector rule: Article 17 of Royal Decree no. 1326 of 1914 provides for posting "the list of those admitted to the oral exam" at the door of the exam room. The list instead also included those not admitted and unnecessary data (date of birth, envelope numbers, scores), and could be reached by anyone entering the lobby, with no check that they were a candidate: in substance, a disclosure to the public without a legal basis.
What the Garante decided
- Publishing also those not admitted, when the rule provides only for those admitted, is processing without a legal basis (Art. 5(1)(a) and (c) and Art. 6(1)(c) and (e) GDPR; Art. 2-ter of the Italian Privacy Code).
- Date of birth, envelope number and detailed scores are not needed to make the outcome known: they breach data minimisation.
- A place "equivalent" to the exam-room door is not, if anyone can reach it without checks: the result is public disclosure.
- The Notaries' Council altered the publicity regime by asking an examiner for the list and sharing it early, including the version with unofficial notes.
The Garante also recalls the general rule introduced in 2025 for public competitions: rankings with only successful candidates are made available in an area restricted to participants (Art. 35(5-quater) and (5-quinquies), Legislative Decree 165/2001). The conduct had ended, so no further measures were ordered; the decision on the Ministry will be published on the Garante's website as an ancillary sanction.
The check for public bodies, professional orders and recruiting companies
Take the latest ranking or results list you published and ask: who does the rule that provides for it say to include, and where? Usually only successful candidates, without date of birth or partial scores, in an area restricted to participants. Also check who, on the board or in the offices, can send lists outside: an individual sending remains the controller's problem if instructions do not prevent it.
The case shows two different mistakes with the same root: treating a results list as a document to circulate, rather than as personal data with a precise publicity regime. It applies to public competitions, but also to selections by professional orders, training bodies and companies that communicate test results.
On DPO Workspace, in the client's file, the record of processing covers recruitment with legal basis and recipients, and the document generator has the candidate privacy notice and the confidentiality undertaking for examiners and external collaborators.
Official source:Garante per la protezione dei dati personali — Newsletter n. 555 del 29 ottobre 2026Official source:Garante per la protezione dei dati personali — provvedimento n. 761 del 7 ottobre 2026 [doc. web 10309500]Official source:Garante per la protezione dei dati personali — provvedimento n. 762 del 7 ottobre 2026 [doc. web 10311438]Looking for a workspace for your DPO work?
DPO Workspace is built by a certified DPO. 30-day free trial.
Start free