What happened
A patient of the Centro Radiologico Madonna della Bruna in Matera received his report by email and noticed that the PDF page was identified only by a number in the web address: changing it opened other patients' reports, with no login. The Garante's staff checked with an ordinary browser and saw name, surname, date of birth, tax code, address, medical history and test results, often with the reporting doctor's name. In decisions no. 764 and 754 of 7 October 2026 the Garante fined the Centre €16,000 and its vendor MedStore Saronno, acting as processor, €12,000.
The vendor explained that the fix already existed in a new software release distributed to customers with an active support contract; the Centre's contract had expired, and the patch was installed only the day after the alarm call. Meanwhile a second problem had surfaced: because automatic deletion was failing, reports stayed available beyond the 30 days set by the Centre and beyond the 45 days in the Garante's 2009 guidelines on online medical reports. Reports from 2021 could still be reached.
What the Garante decided
- The Centre is liable even though the vendor ran the platform entirely and alone held the credentials: the controller must supervise and verify the security of what the processor does on its behalf (Art. 5(1)(f), 25 and 32 GDPR).
- A 30-day deletion setting is not enough: there must be procedures to test regularly that it actually works (Art. 32(1)(d)). Keeping data beyond the limit breaches storage limitation (Art. 5(1)(e)).
- The "minor breach" argument was rejected: reaching the data needed no developer skills, just a browser and a different number in the URL.
- MedStore is liable for the platform's security (Art. 5(1)(f) and 32). It already had a relevant prior infringement from 2021, an aggravating factor.
The amount reflects the health data, the potentially high number of patients and the duration of the breach; in the Centre's favour, its immediate reaction (the server was shut down on receiving the notice) and its cooperation. Breaches of Art. 9 and 28 were treated as absorbed by the security findings. Both injunctions will be published on the Garante's website.
The check for anyone publishing reports or documents online
Open a document from your portal, copy the address and try it in a private window, then change the last digit: if anything opens, stop the service. Then ask your vendor, in writing, which version is installed, which security patches are missing and whether the contract covers them. Finally, check that automatic deletion works: pick a document older than the limit and make sure it is gone.
The case shows the weak spot of many small and mid-sized healthcare providers: the platform "belongs to the vendor", but the responsibility stays with the controller. An expired maintenance contract is not a paperwork issue when it includes security updates, and a retention period written in a configuration is no guarantee until someone checks it.
In DPO Workspace, the client record has a processors section with service and contract status, and the document generator includes the processor appointment, the vendor questionnaire and the IT security questionnaire. The Retention module helps set and document periods for each category of document.
Official source:Garante per la protezione dei dati personali — Newsletter n. 556 del 12 novembre 2026Official source:Garante per la protezione dei dati personali — provvedimento n. 764 del 7 ottobre 2026 [doc. web 10311455]Official source:Garante per la protezione dei dati personali — provvedimento n. 754 del 7 ottobre 2026 [doc. web 10312186]Looking for a workspace for your DPO work?
DPO Workspace is built by a certified DPO. 30-day free trial.
Start free